Although I can not reject this as a possibility, such leader would surely be taken down by a rebellion. Therefore, I agree with both Hobbes and Locke, just on different points. Thomas Hobbes and John Locke Vs.Voltaire Locke and Ideas of Liberty Locke’s Natural Rights Locke on Colonial Self-Government By: Seanna Garewal, Josue and Max Sandoval & Henry Bermejo Class: History 111 Period: 2 Locke and the Enlightenment John Locke an English philosopher and Rousseau wrote that the process made by civilization and enlightenment had corrupted the human nature. I agree with Hobbes because it is true, humans do all want the same thing, to be successful, normal is not enough and most of us will do anything to get to the top. I agree with Thomas Hobbes view on human's original State of Nature. The Enlightenment, taking place in France and dominating European philosophy during the eighteenth-century, gave birth to many new ideas regarding legitimacy of authority and governmental power. Locke seemed more peaceful while Voltaire seemed rebellious. In this paper, the John Locke second treatise on government is compared to Voltaire Candide. Where does each go wrong, and how?I agree with different parts of there theory. Thus is the Enlightenment movement in which society should continue to endorse the freedom to question current situations and knowledge in order continue the ongoing process. throughout the Enlightenment had voiced their opinions on how to make a government run more effectively. If punishments are declared, it is of course in anyone's self interest to veer away from wrongdoing. If people are uncontrollable, as Hobbes suggested, then a dictator is not going to help society. This achievement is, as Jonathan Israel has recently shown, hardly as radical as has sometimes been thought: the English thinkers in question served essentially as a deistic Réflexions d’une provinciale sur le discours de M. Rousseau, citoyen de Genève, touchant l’origine de l’inegalité des conditions parmi les hommes (BV 5– 116)). Thomas Hobbes had the right idea when describing raw human nature as over-protective and selfish, in addition to noting that a strict government would help contain such problematic characteristics.This question, then, is for both Danielle and Nicole--how can you believe in both? Enlightenment, however… In terms of the history of ideas, Voltaire’s single most important achievement was to have helped in the 1730s to introduce the thought of Newton and Locke to France (and so to the rest of the Continent).
However, i agree with Locke, because everyone is free to do whatever he or she needs to do to survive.Generally, I agree with Hobbes's theory that humans are uncontrollable in the State of Nature. Hobbes vs. Locke and Voltaire's Opinion on Equality After Friday’s reading I have two topics that I would like discuss. Instead, an assembly of representatives, as Locke suggested, is better because it would not attempt to suppress its people. Clearly their ideas are contradictory at certain points. Also, as i stated above, in a sense, everyone in not equal. Montesquieu had a different…defined enlightenment as "emancipation from self-incurred tutelage", and while it is certainly true that enlightenment writers and thinkers were capable of profound disagreement among themselves, it is the common aspiration that Kant identifies which allows us to see a unified movement amongst diversity.
For example, Locke believed that in state of nature, people would be naturally equal; every person is free to do what he or she needs to do to survive. Men live in constant state of war. The Enlightenment was a remarkable time for development and it had a substantial influence in the United States government.
Wanted a government that let people have a say in decisions and was accepted by all citizens Locke supported religion while Volatire didn't. Voltaire, Hobbes And Locke Was The Declaration Of Enlightenment. Many philosophers of the time such as Rousseau, Montesquieu, Voltaire, Hobbes, and Locke had many different ideal forms of government and major beliefs, shaping today’s world. Locke's positive philosophy was influential, including in France (and yes, publicised by Voltaire.) Political philosopher and naturalist John Locke witnessed all the events and was compelled by them which led him to writing what is known as Second Treatise on government … Whereas Hobbes believed that men are naturally enemies because they all want the same things, they fight because they see themselves as more valuable then others. The United States would not be the same if it were not for gaining our independence from Great Britain in 1776 with the help of Enlightenment thinkers…The Enlightenment, taking place in France and dominating European philosophy during the eighteenth-century, gave birth to many new ideas regarding legitimacy of authority and governmental power.